Is Mainstream Tourism a Good Way to Save Helpless Antarctica?

Is Mainstream Tourism a Good Way to Save Helpless Antarctica?

Setting sail from Ushuaia, the southernmost city in South America, they embarked on an expedition to Antarctica accompanied by a diverse team of experts including scientific researchers, marine biologists, and seasoned Antarctic guides. This journey wasn't just a voyage but an immersive encounter with the impacts of global warming in one of the planet's most remote and pristine environments.
 

In this article, they examined three critical facets of climate change's impact on Antarctica: increasing temperatures in the Southern Ocean, the diminishing capacity of the Antarctic ecosystem to absorb carbon dioxide, and the effects of warmer oceans on wildlife populations. Despite the urgency of these issues, public awareness remains disturbingly low. Scientists are issuing urgent warnings, advocating for greater attention and action, recognizing that changes in Antarctica have far-reaching consequences that extend globally and could lead to catastrophic outcomes.
 

They also explored the potential of responsible tourism as a potent tool for conservation efforts. While this industry poses risks to the Antarctic ecosystem, it also presents significant opportunities for scientific research and public education, both crucial in the endeavor to preserve this continent.

Navigating Climate Change in Antarctica’s Warming Waters

 

They embarked on a voyage across the Southern Ocean, eager to witness firsthand the breathtaking beauty of Antarctica. These expeditions primarily occur during the Antarctic summer, from December to February, when milder weather and ice-free passages allow ships to navigate freely. Their journey encountered a significant transition around 60° South latitude in the Drake Passage, a narrow stretch of water between Cape Horn (Chile) and the Antarctic Peninsula. Here, they crossed into the Antarctic Convergence Zone, where the Antarctic Circumpolar Current (ACC) meets waters from the Pacific, Atlantic, and Southern Oceans.
 

Amidst this natural spectacle lies a troubling reality. Each summer, Antarctic temperatures rise, underscoring the urgent need to address climate change. Research stations in Antarctica have documented unprecedented temperature highs in recent years. For instance, Argentina's Esperanza station recorded a maximum of 18.3°C (64.94°F) in 2020, and in 2022, the Concordia station—operated jointly by France and Italy—reported a peak of 47°C (116.6°F). These fluctuations highlight alarming weather anomalies unfolding in Antarctica.
 

Surges in temperatures disrupt the Antarctic Circumpolar Current (ACC), altering the exchange of carbon dioxide between the oceans and the atmosphere, intensifying warming, and reshaping oceanic currents.
 

Antarctica’s Global Warming Mitigation is in Jeopardy

 
Zodiac Boats | Antarctica
Photo: Lorena Del Castillo


The melting of ice sheets, primarily driven by warmer oceans, triggers a chain of immediate consequences with significant global weather implications. One consequence is the reduction in Earth's overall albedo—its surface reflectivity. Ice sheets reflect a substantial amount of sunlight back into space, which helps to cool the planet. As ice coverage diminishes, less solar radiation is reflected and more is absorbed by the ocean, further heating it.
 

Ice sheets also serve as a protective barrier, insulating the cooler environment below and assisting in temperature regulation. Their presence enhances this reflective quality, promoting cooler temperatures and supporting crucial algae growth essential to the Antarctic ecosystem. Decreasing sea ice coverage disrupts the environment that fosters algae growth, leading to a decline in algae populations. This reduction negatively impacts the ocean's ability to absorb greenhouse gases. Algae are a primary food source for krill, so their decline results in a decrease in krill populations.
 

Krill play a vital role in mitigating climate change. After consuming algae that have absorbed atmospheric carbon dioxide, large swarms of krill migrate to deeper waters, where they excrete waste, effectively sequestering carbon in the ocean depths. This process is crucial for combating rising temperatures.
 

Another significant concern stemming from climate change is ocean acidification, often termed the "neglected sibling of global warming." Approximately 30% of the carbon dioxide emitted into the atmosphere ultimately enters the oceans, increasing acidity levels. The cold waters of the Southern Ocean facilitate this process by absorbing a substantial amount of carbon dioxide, intensifying acidification. This poses a serious threat to krill, as it interferes with their growth cycle. Acidic oceans also challenge corals and mollusks in building and maintaining their structures, disrupting marine food webs and impacting various forms of marine life.
 

The Shifting Landscape for Antarctica’s Wildlife

 
Penguins rest on sea ice | Antarctica
Photo: Lorena Del Castillo


As they sailed through the Southern Ocean, the looming threat of climate change was impossible to ignore. Despite traveling during the Antarctic summer, temperatures hovered between 0°C to 5°C (41°F), reminiscent of a typical autumn day in their native Holland. They couldn't help but contemplate how this milder climate was impacting the surrounding region.
 

Two days after departing from Ushuaia, their expedition reached Brown Bluff Beach, one of the northernmost points of Antarctica. After undergoing a disinfection process to prevent any organic material from contaminating the Antarctic Peninsula, they boarded a zodiac boat to reach the beach. Despite strong winds, they pressed on and had their first encounter with penguins.
 

Setting foot on land was immediately rewarding. They disembarked amidst a colony of Adélie penguins and ice formations on the shore. The birds moved about, seemingly unaffected by their presence. As they continued exploring Antarctica, they encountered diverse wildlife such as whales, seals, and birds throughout their journey. After discovering the Adélie penguin colony at Brown Bluff, they observed elephant seals at President's Head on Snow Island and witnessed a colony of Gentoo penguins in Neko Harbor. The expedition's scientific experts highlighted the profound impact of global warming on these Antarctic species. Despite appearing resilient, Adélie penguins are highly susceptible to environmental changes. Their population declined by 40% from 2012 to 2022, underscoring the urgency of their plight. Rising temperatures, which lead to sea ice melting, pose a serious threat to their survival.
 

Adélie penguins are not alone in facing these challenges. Emperor penguins, adapted to colder climates, have also encountered significant setbacks in recent years. With diminishing ice coverage, penguins are forced to travel farther into the sea in search of prey, consuming more energy. This results in reduced food intake for both adults and chicks, exacerbating hunger and chick mortality. Warmer weather also brings heavier snowfall, which can bury penguin eggs and expose chicks to hypothermia. The loss of suitable nesting sites due to melting ice further reduces their chances of successful breeding.
 

Antarctic marine mammals are similarly affected by climate change. Rising ocean temperatures impact their food sources, with krill-dependent species like whales facing particular vulnerability. Any disruptions in krill populations or behaviors can cascade through the ecosystem, jeopardizing the entire Antarctic food chain.
 

Luciana Motta, an ecologist and marine mammal expert on the expedition, emphasized the significant challenges these animals face in adapting to changes in their habitats and foraging grounds. Global warming, alongside increased fishing activities and competition for food resources, poses a grave threat to the marine ecosystem, potentially leading to species extinctions.
 

With Antarctic temperatures rising due to global warming, critical food sources such as krill are declining, endangering species like Weddell seals, leopard seals, and minke whales. Motta stressed the importance of effectively communicating research findings to highlight the urgency of conservation efforts and advocate for policy changes aimed at mitigating the impacts of climate change on Antarctic biodiversity.
 

A Weddell seal lounges on the rocks | Antarctica
Photo: Lorena Del Castillo


Climate Change’s Reach from the Southern Continent to Our Doorstep

 

The transformations occurring in Antarctica have profound global implications, yet public awareness remains limited. James McClintock, a senior researcher at the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) with extensive experience in Antarctic expedition cruises, points out the disconnect: "Many people in the United States and around the world are disconnected from the realities of Antarctica, leading to a lack of interest. As a result, there is widespread ignorance about the critical role this continent plays in maintaining global environmental balance. Much of the public is unaware that current developments in Antarctica are already affecting the entire planet."
 

Vulnerable low-lying island nations, already struggling with limited resources, face increasing risks. Rising sea levels continue to encroach upon their shores, eroding land and threatening communities. Traditional practices such as subsistence hunting in places like Alaska and Greenland are under pressure as animals adapt to shifting migration patterns.
 

Coastal regions like Bangladesh are experiencing heightened salinity levels due to rising seas, which hinder agricultural productivity. Erratic weather patterns driven by increasing temperatures in the Southern Ocean, including heavy rainfall, prolonged droughts, and destructive floods, pose challenges for farmers and exacerbate food insecurity.
 

Communities across diverse regions from Alaska to Alabama confront the looming threats of famine, displacement, and coastal erosion as a result of these ongoing changes.
 

Conscious Tourists Can Advocate for Antarctica

 

Conscious travelers can advocate for Antarctica's preservation amidst the rising tourism to the continent. The International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators (IAATO) reports a significant increase in visitors during the 2023-2024 season, with concerns mounting over its environmental impact. Established in 1991 by private tour operators, IAATO aims to guide tourism responsibly, though adherence to its guidelines remains voluntary, posing risks from independent operators driven by commercial interests.
 

Studies highlight environmental threats such as increased black carbon in snow near tourist sites, accelerating melting, and the introduction of non-native species like the avian flu outbreak in 2023. Despite these risks, tourism also presents opportunities for conservation. Exposure to Antarctica's beauty can inspire travelers to support sustainable practices, while collaborations between tour operators and scientists facilitate vital research and data collection on its ecosystem.
 

Efforts to achieve net-zero emissions and strict controls on landings are crucial for mitigating tourism's impact. Compliance with IAATO regulations, including limits on daily visitors and landings, is essential to safeguard Antarctica's delicate environment for future generations.
 

Visit Antarctica with us aboard the Ocean Albatros